The everyday one
Best for most people, most nights.

- Safe with every toy, silicone included
- Tasteless and odorless, so it is the one for oral
- Rinses off with warm water, no residue on sheets
- Vegan, pH-balanced, paraben-free
Long-lasting, lightweight, colorless and condom-compatible personal lubricant. Approved by our two board-certified urologists.
Get 2 or more lubes and save $2.50 per bottle
Not sure which? See the short answer below ↓Best for most people, most nights.

Best for longer sessions and water.
Most people end up with one of each anyway, the water-based for toys and oral, the silicone for the shower. Get 2 or more lubes and save $2.50 per bottle.
Both are approved by two board-certified urologists. Here is where they differ.
| Feature | Water-based | Silicone-based |
|---|---|---|
| Feel | Silky, gel-like | Ultra-slick, satiny |
| Staying power | Long-lasting, refresh as needed | Longest-lasting, rarely needs a top-up |
| Shower and bath | Washes away | Water-resistant, made for it |
| Silicone toys | Yes, safe with all toys | Not recommended |
| Condoms | Latex, polyisoprene and polyurethane | Latex, polyisoprene and polyurethane |
| Cleanup | Rinses off with water | Soap and warm water |
| Ingredients | Vegan, pH-balanced, hypoallergenic, paraben-free | Glycerin-free and paraben-free |
| Best for | Everyday use, toys, zero-fuss cleanup | Long sessions and shower play |
If anything in the drawer is silicone, and most are, water based is the only safe answer. Silicone lube eats silicone toys.
Water based washes straight off the second it gets wet. Silicone is the only one that survives.
Both are body safe, but water based is tasteless and odorless and rinses clean, so it is the easier one to have around.
A long session with no stopping to reapply is exactly what silicone is for. A little goes a long way.
Silicone sits on the skin rather than absorbing, and has four ingredients with no glycerin, which suits sensitive skin.
Honestly the most common ending. Water based for toys and oral, silicone for the shower and the long nights.
Popstar Play is approved by Dr. Joshua Gonzalez and Dr. Brian Steixner, two board-certified urologists who spend their working lives on men's sexual health. It is the lube they recommend.
Water based lube is mostly water, so it feels like a gel, rinses off with warm water, and is safe with every toy material. Silicone lube doesn't absorb into skin or wash off in water, which makes it last far longer. The tradeoff is that it damages silicone toys and needs soap to clean up.
Water based, for most people. It works with every toy, it's fine for oral, and cleanup is nothing. Buy silicone instead if your main use is in the shower or you want one application to last the whole session.
No. Silicone lube breaks down the surface of silicone toys over time. Use water based with silicone toys. Silicone lube is fine with glass, stainless steel and marble.
Yes, both. Latex, polyisoprene and polyurethane.
Popstar Play is cleared by the FDA as a medical device through the 510(k) pathway, the route personal lubricants take to market.
Both are colorless, odorless and non-staining.
Popstar Volume + Taste is the one that made us. Find out how to make a big impression.